Ann Dumaliang
Cover Ann Dumaliang is the co-founder of Masungi Georeserve

Across the globe, more young people are expressing anger about climate change. And that, experts say, may not necessarily be a bad thing

From clickbait articles calling Gen Z lazy, all the way back to Aristotle, who said young people “high-minded because they have not yet been humbled by life,” reactionary voices tend to undermine the advocacy of young voters due to their supposed inexperience of hard times. Yet, when it comes to climate change, hundreds of thousands of young people have made their beliefs clearly felt.

In 2018, 15-year-old schoolgirl Greta Thunberg sat outside the Swedish parliament, demanding climate action. Six years later, Thunberg’s solo protest has grown into a global youth movement, involving millions of young people from around 270 countries. She has inspired activists like Lance Lau, one of the most recognisable eco-warriors in Hong Kong, who organised his first climate protest when he was just aged 10.

In 2024, young people across the world are marching in the streets, launching school strikes, petitioning politicians and taking governments to court in a bid to get climate action. In Australia, for example, a student-run network made history with a 350,000-strong rally across the country in 2021, the largest climate mobilisation in Australia's history. The protesters ignored pleas from the government to stay in school, arguing that more action is needed to address the climate crisis.

As the window to curb global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius closes, more young people are getting angry about climate change. And researchers think that’s not necessarily a bad thing.

Don't miss: Young climate activist Lance Lau on his mission to save the planet

Tatler Asia
Lance Lau Hin-yi
Above Lance Lau Hin-yi started organising school strikes in Hong Kong at the age of 10 (Photo: Jacob Liu)

Anger, fear and other emotions

At the conclusion of the COP26 UN Climate Change Conference in November 2021, UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres called the resulting agreements a “compromise”, saying that they “take important steps, but unfortunately the collective political will was not enough to overcome some deep contradictions.” Greta Thunberg was more straightforward, calling it a failure.

People concerned about climate change often mention feeling angry or frustrated, which experts refer to as ‘climate anger’ or ‘eco-anger’. A 2022 study discovered that climate change evoked feelings of anger, shame, guilt and disappointment among its 530 respondents aged 16 to 24 in the UK. They felt guilty about their own contributions to climate change and were uncertain that their actions to combat it would have any significant effect.  

Researchers in the US also reported an increase in climate anger among young people. Drawing from a survey of 20,000 respondents, they found younger generations felt greater anger because they felt their futures were at risk, blaming older generations for the crisis.

And then there is also ‘climate anxiety’. A survey of a thousand young people (aged 16 to 25) each in Australia, Brazil, Finland, France, India, Nigeria, Philippines, Portugal, the UK, and the USA found that, while young people across all countries were worried about climate change (59% were very or extremely worried and 84% were at least moderately worried), more respondents from the Philippines, India and Brazil reported feelings of fear and anxiety than respondents from Australia, UK and France. Heightened worry was lowest in the United States, where 46 percent of young people surveyed felt concerned about climate change. 

Tatler Asia
Greta Thunberg
Above Greta Thunberg outside the Swedish parliament building in August 2018, where she started a school strike for the climate (photo by Anders Hellberg, CC BY-SA 4.0)

The content of climate anger

The anger of young people towards climate change has a few causes. One is human action or inaction. The previously mentioned ten-nation study correlated climate anxiety with perceived inadequate government response and associated feelings of betrayal.

The double injustice of climate change where the least responsible for causing it are most harmed and have the fewest resources to cope with its consequences, also drew anger from younger generations, according to this paper from Norway. Another study covering four island nations found expressions of anger were related to an inability to create change for the future.

Anger was also relevant when participants felt a lack of engagement from those in power or people in general. Young people who felt their emotions and concerns about climate change were not listened to or silenced felt angry and betrayed.

“We have more access to information and technology that allows us to connect with each other more. We also have a better understanding of the impact of our choices. It is good that we are disturbed; to me, it is an acceptable reaction when you fully understand the issue.”

- Ann Dumaliang -

Anger as a fuel for action

In an interview with Tatler in 2022, Masungi Georeserve co-founder Ann Dumaliang said that it was her feelings of solastagia—which she described as “a form of eco-anxiety felt by individuals when they see their environment changing negatively through time”—that finally drove her to become an activist. In fact, she sees those negative feelings as a good sign: “It is good that we are disturbed; to me, it is an acceptable reaction when you fully understand the issue.”

While conventional wisdom indicates that anger has negative effects on health and well-being, a 2023 study, for example, shows that anger is a powerful enough emotion to spur climate action

Researchers from the London School of Economics stress the power of mobilising anger to increase collective action to remedy a perceived injustice. They claim that anger works as a motivational signal that convinces more people that others will soon act and this makes them want to join.

A growing body of research also indicates that expressions of public outrage are more likely to be re-shared on social media sites than neutral content. 

Other scholars contend that expressions of collective outrage, like climate marches, helped promote information-seeking about climate change. A study in Australia further revealed that expressions of negative emotions about climate can help one’s mental health.

Don't miss: “Resilience is a muscle that gets stronger as it is exercised”: Conservationist Ann Dumaliang on overcoming eco-anxiety

Maintaining the rage

Given our climate change predicament, young people are right to be mad. Some will eventually feel overwhelmed and burned out. Providing safe spaces for them to continue to voice their climate anger may help prevent that. Being heard can help address feelings of powerlessness, as well as build camaraderie and support. 

The adults also need to do their part. Adult allies who acknowledge intergenerational injustices, validate emotional experiences and support youth capabilities can help provide reassurance and fuel transformative action. These strategies will help ensure that the fight of our young people for a more liveable and sustainable future will not lose its momentum. 


Dr Justin See is a postdoctoral research fellow in climate change adaptation from the Sydney Environment Institute at the University of Sydney.

Originally published under Creative Commons by 360info™. Additional information and editing from Tatler on 21 March 2024.

Credits

Styling  

on Lance Lau: Stephanie Levy (Shirt and swim shorts, available at Retykle)

Topics